If you've ever lain in bed thinking "I have to fall asleep now," you've probably noticed it doesn't work. Sleep researchers have a name for this: sleep effort, the attempt to make yourself fall asleep through willpower. It's one of the ideas behind modern insomnia treatment, and once you understand it, a lot of common sleep advice starts to look a little different.

This article explains what sleep effort is, what the research says about it, how to tell whether it's part of your own bad nights, and what you can do instead of trying harder.

  • Sleep is an automatic process, so direct attempts to force it can backfire.
  • In one experiment, people told to fall asleep as fast as possible took longer to fall asleep when their minds were busy.
  • Sleep researchers measure sleep effort with a questionnaire, and treatments that reduce it are part of insomnia care.
  • Useful steps include turning the clock away, aiming for rest instead of sleep, and getting up when you're wide awake.

What is sleep effort?

Sleep effort is the work people put into trying to fall asleep: concentrating on it, monitoring whether it's happening, and getting frustrated when it isn't. Two University of Glasgow researchers, Broomfield and Espie, described the problem when they developed a scale to measure it. Sleep is "an involuntary physiological process, which cannot be placed under full voluntary control," so direct attempts to control it may make insomnia worse and keep it going (Broomfield & Espie, 2005).

A useful comparison is digestion or blushing. These things happen on their own when the conditions are right, and focusing hard on making them happen tends to get in the way. For most people who sleep well, falling asleep isn't something they think about; they lie down and it happens.

Espie and colleagues later described how insomnia can develop along an "attention–intention–effort pathway": paying close attention to sleep, explicitly intending to sleep and putting effort into it, which together interfere with the automatic process that normally takes over at bedtime (Espie et al., 2006).

What the research shows

Trying to fall asleep fast can slow you down

In a study at the University of Virginia, normal sleepers were told either to fall asleep as quickly as they could or to fall asleep whenever they liked. Some listened to calm new age music, others to lively John Philip Sousa marches, which kept their minds busier. With the calm music, the people trying hard did fall asleep a bit faster. With the marches, the result flipped: people trying to fall asleep quickly took longer than people who weren't trying (Ansfield, Wegner & Bowser, 1996).

That matters because a busy mind at bedtime is exactly when most people try hardest. If your head is full of tomorrow's problems, effort is more likely to backfire.

Watching for sleep keeps your attention on it

People with insomnia tend to keep part of their attention on sleep-related cues. In one experiment, people with primary insomnia were slower than good sleepers to pull their attention away from images of a clock showing nighttime hours (Woods et al., 2009). Checking the time and calculating how many hours are left is a very ordinary form of sleep effort, and it keeps sleep at the center of your attention when you want it in the background.

Pushing thoughts away brings them back

A lot of sleep effort goes into trying to stop thinking. The classic "white bear" experiments found that people told not to think about a white bear kept thinking about it, and thought about it even more once they were allowed to (Wegner et al., 1987). Trying to empty your mind at bedtime runs into the same problem.

Signs that sleep effort is part of your bad nights

Ask yourself whether these sound familiar:

  • You go to bed thinking about how much sleep you need to get tonight.
  • You check the clock in the night and work out how many hours are left.
  • You feel frustrated or anxious when you're not asleep within a certain time.
  • You try to force your mind to go blank.
  • You've built a strict routine and feel that one slip will ruin the night.
  • You sleep better on the sofa, in a hotel or when you weren't planning to sleep.

That last one is a common clue. When the pressure is off, sleep often turns up on its own. Researchers measure this more formally with the Glasgow Sleep Effort Scale (Broomfield & Espie, 2005), but you don't need a questionnaire to notice the pattern in yourself.

How to stop trying so hard to sleep

None of these involve trying to relax, since "trying to relax" is another form of effort. They work by lowering the stakes.

Turn the clock away

If you can see the time from your pillow, turn the clock around or put your phone across the room. You lose nothing by not knowing it's 3:14, and you skip the arithmetic that follows. Middle-of-the-night thinking has its own problems, which we cover in why everything feels worse at 2 a.m.

Aim for rest instead of sleep

Tell yourself that lying in the dark with your eyes closed is a perfectly good use of the night, and let sleep come if it wants to. This lowers the bar from "fall asleep now" to "rest," which you're already doing.

Give your mind something light to follow

A quiet story, a slow walk through a familiar place in your imagination, or a detailed scene you build in your head gives your attention somewhere to go that isn't sleep. In a study of people with insomnia, an engaging imagery task helped them fall asleep faster and have fewer unwanted thoughts than having no instructions (Harvey & Payne, 2002). Our guide on how to stop racing thoughts at night has more on this.

Empty your head onto paper first

If tomorrow's tasks are the reason you're trying so hard to switch off, write them down before bed. A worry list before bed gives those thoughts somewhere to go, so you're not using willpower to hold them back.

Get up when you're wide awake

If you're getting more alert and more frustrated, get out of bed, go somewhere dim and do something quiet until you feel sleepy. This comes from stimulus control, one of the insomnia treatments suggested by the American Academy of Sleep Medicine (Edinger et al., 2021). It also ends the struggle, which is the point.

Try paradoxical intention

Paradoxical intention means lying in bed in the dark and gently trying to stay awake, with your eyes open, instead of trying to sleep. It sounds odd, but it targets the pressure directly. In a study of 34 people with sleep-onset insomnia, two weeks of paradoxical intention reduced their sleep effort and their anxiety about sleep compared with a control group. It didn't produce a measurable change in how fast they fell asleep on wrist-worn sleep trackers, though there was a trend toward people feeling they fell asleep faster (Broomfield & Espie, 2003).

Don't fight to keep yourself awake. Lie comfortably, keep your eyes open in the dark, and if they want to close, let them.

Where Nightjar fits. Nightjar never tells you to relax or to fall asleep. You write down what's on your mind, seal it in the jar, and listen to a story that winds down slowly and fades out on its own. The idea is to give your mind something easy to follow so sleep can arrive without you chasing it.

Sleep hygiene can turn into sleep effort

Common sleep hygiene advice, like a cool room, regular hours and less caffeine, is reasonable. The trouble starts when the rules become a performance, and every slip feels like a reason the night will go badly. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine's guideline suggests that clinicians not use sleep hygiene on its own as a treatment for chronic insomnia (Edinger et al., 2021). Keep the habits that make your evenings pleasant, and drop the ones you're anxiously policing.

When to get help

If you've had trouble sleeping most nights for weeks, or it's affecting your days, talk to a doctor. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine strongly recommends cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) for chronic insomnia in adults (Edinger et al., 2021). CBT-I programs work on many of the same ideas covered here, with a trained clinician guiding you through them.

Frequently asked questions

Why can I fall asleep on the couch but not in bed?

On the couch you usually aren't trying to sleep, so there's no pressure. In bed, sleep becomes the goal and a measure of success. If your bed has also become linked with lying awake, that adds to it, which is why getting up when you're wide awake can help.

Is it bad to try to fall asleep?

Lying down in a dark room when you're sleepy is all the "trying" sleep needs. The effort that causes problems is the mental kind: monitoring, forcing and getting frustrated.

Does paradoxical intention work for everyone?

No single technique works for everyone, and the research on paradoxical intention is limited. It's worth trying if you notice yourself straining to sleep. If your insomnia is long-term, a doctor or a CBT-I program can help you decide what to try.

Nightjar is a relaxation aid, not medical care. If sleep problems last for weeks or affect your days, talk to a doctor.