If you're weighing up BetterSleep vs Nightjar, you probably want something on your phone that makes bedtime easier, and you'd like to know which one is worth trying first. The short answer is that they suit different people and different nights. BetterSleep is a large, long-running sleep app with sounds, meditations, stories and sleep tracking, while Nightjar is a small iPhone app built around one bedtime ritual for nights when worry is the thing keeping you up.
- BetterSleep is the better choice if you want a big library, a sound mixer, sleep tracking, or an app on Android, Apple Watch or several languages.
- Nightjar is built for one situation: lying awake with something on your mind.
- Nightjar asks you to write the worry down and seal it in a jar before a story plays; BetterSleep offers meditations and sounds aimed at a racing mind.
- Both are free to download with a paid subscription, and some people happily use both.
BetterSleep vs Nightjar at a glance
| BetterSleep | Nightjar | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A broad sleep and relaxation app (formerly Relax Melodies) with audio content, a sleep tracker and a sleep recorder | A bedtime ritual app: write down what's keeping you up, seal it in a jar, then listen to a sleep story |
| Main content | 300+ sleep sounds and music tracks, 250+ meditations and hypnosis sessions, 100+ SleepTales and stories | Original sleep stories, plus optional sleep sounds (crickets, fireplace, ocean waves, piano, stream, white noise) |
| Approach to a busy mind at bedtime | Meditations such as "Releasing Worry for Sleep", a stress and anxiety relief category, and sound mixes | You write the worry in a private note, it's sealed until morning, and a story matched to that kind of worry plays |
| Platforms | iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Watch, Apple TV, Apple Vision and Android | iPhone only (iOS 18 or later) |
| Languages | 10 languages on the App Store, including English, French, German, Japanese and Spanish | English only |
| How it's priced | Free to download; free trial, then an auto-renewing subscription; a limited selection of free content stays available without one | Free to download; Nightjar Premium subscription gives access to the full catalog |
| Voices and narration | Narrated sleep stories; the official pages don't say who the narrators are | Original stories, AI-generated and narrated by an AI voice |
What BetterSleep does well
BetterSleep has been around a long time (it used to be called Relax Melodies), and it shows in the size of the library. The App Store listing lists more than 300 sleep sounds and music tracks, from nature sounds and white noise to binaural beats and 3D sounds, along with more than 250 meditations and hypnosis sessions and more than 100 SleepTales and stories in genres like fairy tales, mystery, sci-fi and history. If you like having lots of choice every night, there's plenty to explore.
The sound mixer is one of its best-known features. On the BetterSleep website you can layer sounds by tapping icons, and the app lets you save favorite mixes, build playlists and set timers. A feature called Smart Mix is designed to hide the loop point in repeating sounds, which matters if you listen to rain or a fan all night.
BetterSleep also goes beyond audio. It includes a sleep tracker that suggests ways to improve your sleep, a sleep recorder that picks up snoring and sleep talking, bedtime reminders, and some sleep science content, including a chronotype feature. It can optionally connect to Apple Health.
For people with a racing mind, the website highlights meditations with titles like "Releasing Worry for Sleep" and "Letting Go of Your Day", and the App Store listing includes a stress and anxiety relief category.
It's also available almost everywhere. The App Store lists iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Watch, Apple TV and Apple Vision, there's an Android version on Google Play, and the app comes in ten languages. On pricing, the website says you get full access during a free trial, then an auto-renewing subscription, with a limited selection of free content still available if you don't subscribe.
How Nightjar is different
Nightjar does one thing at bedtime and is built around it. Before lights out, the app asks a single question: what's keeping you up tonight? You write the answer in a private note, which is encrypted on your iPhone. The note folds into a glowing orb, drops into a jar, and stays sealed until morning.
Then Nightjar plays an original sleep story matched, on the device, to that kind of worry. The worry itself never appears in the story. The stories wind down in four quieter stages and fade out on their own, and you can add a sleep sound underneath if you like. In the morning the jar opens and asks whether the worry is still on your mind or feels smaller. The whole ritual takes about 30 seconds, on a near-black screen.
The thinking behind this comes from sleep research. Writing tomorrow's tasks down before bed seems to take them off your mind: in one 2018 sleep-lab study, people who wrote a specific to-do list fell asleep about nine minutes faster than people who wrote about tasks they'd already finished (Scullin et al., 2018). Our article on writing a worry list before bed covers that study and others. Nightjar also never tells you to relax, because trying hard to sleep tends to keep people awake (more on that in sleep effort). The worry is sealed rather than deleted, since pushing a thought away usually brings it back.
There are honest limits. Nightjar is a newer, smaller app with a much smaller catalog than BetterSleep. It's iPhone only and English only, with no Android, iPad-specific, Mac or web version. It has no sleep tracker or sound mixer, though it can show your Apple Health sleep data (read on the device, never uploaded). The stories are AI-generated from a writing system the maker developed and narrated by an AI voice, so if a human narrator matters to you, keep that in mind.
Which one should you choose?
BetterSleep is probably the better fit if:
- you want a large library with sounds, music, meditations, hypnosis and stories in one place
- you like building your own sound mixes
- you want sleep tracking or a sleep recorder
- you use Android, an Apple Watch or a Mac, or you'd like the app in a language other than English
Nightjar might suit you better if:
- your bad nights usually start with a worry or a to-do list going round in your head
- you'd rather follow a short ritual than choose from a big menu at midnight
- you like the idea of writing a worry down and coming back to it in the morning
- you use an iPhone and are happy with English
Plenty of people use more than one app. You could use Nightjar on nights when something is on your mind and BetterSleep's sound mixes on nights when you mostly want background noise. Both are free to download, so trying each for a few nights is a reasonable way to find out what helps you wind down.
Frequently asked questions
Is BetterSleep good for sleep?
BetterSleep is a well-established relaxation app with a big library of sleep sounds, meditations and stories, and many people like it as part of their bedtime routine. Like any sleep app, it's a relaxation aid rather than a treatment. If sleep problems last for weeks, talk to a doctor.
Does BetterSleep have sleep stories?
It does: BetterSleep calls its sleep stories SleepTales, and its App Store listing describes more than 100 of them in genres including fairy tales, mystery, sci-fi, fantasy and history.
Is Nightjar a BetterSleep alternative for racing thoughts?
It can be, if racing thoughts are the main reason you can't sleep. Nightjar's ritual starts by getting the worry out of your head and onto a note before the story plays, which is a different approach from choosing a meditation or a sound mix. For more ideas that work with or without an app, see how to stop racing thoughts at night.
Details checked on the official BetterSleep website and App Store page on November 19, 2026. Features and pricing change, so check the current listing.
Nightjar is a relaxation aid, not medical care. If sleep problems last for weeks or affect your days, talk to a doctor.


